Planning and Estimating · 5 min read
Design and Construction Error Identification · Shop Drawings, Plans, and Specifications
An error caught on paper costs a question; the same error caught after the work is covered costs demolition. The general contractor reviews the documents before bidding, checks installed work before it is concealed, and records every discrepancy in writing.
Design Errors
| Type | Examples |
|---|---|
| Dimensional | Strings that do not add up; plan and detail disagree |
| Scale and reference | Inconsistent detail scales; callout to the wrong sheet |
| Coordination | Beam through a duct run; pipe through a structural member; panel behind a door |
| Code | Narrow egress, noncomplying stair, missing fire rating, accessibility deficiency |
| Constructability | Inaccessible connection, unrealistic tolerance, unavailable material |
Document Review
Review includes the project manager, superintendent, and key subcontractors. Drawings are cross-referenced: architectural plans against structural, reflected ceiling plans against mechanical layouts, the site plan against civil. Specifications are checked against the drawings for conflicting or unavailable materials. A constructability review asks whether the design can be built efficiently.
- Stair risers 7-3/4 in. maximum, treads 10 in. minimum, width 36 in.
- Guards 42 in. high where the drop exceeds 30 in.
- No door from the garage directly into a sleeping room
Construction Errors and Defects
Documenting and Resolving Errors
The contract documents are the drawings, which show location, size, and quantity, and the specifications, which state material quality and workmanship in writing. Together they define what must be built. The approved, stamped permit set is the one that governs in the field.
Drawing Set Organization
| Prefix | Discipline | Shows |
|---|---|---|
| G | General | Title sheet, index |
| C | Civil | Boundaries, grading, utilities |
| L | Landscape | Planting, irrigation |
| A | Architectural | Plans, elevations, sections, details |
| S | Structural | Foundations, framing, connections |
| M | Mechanical | HVAC equipment and ducts |
| P | Plumbing | Piping and fixtures |
| E | Electrical | Power and lighting |
A plan is a horizontal cut viewed from above; an elevation is a view of a vertical face; a section is a vertical slice showing ceiling heights and structure, located by a section mark on the plan. Details enlarge a small area at a larger scale.
Scales and Dimensions
| Scale | Typical use | 1 in. on paper equals |
|---|---|---|
| 1/8 in. = 1 ft | Large floor plans | 8 ft |
| 1/4 in. = 1 ft | Floor plans, elevations | 4 ft |
| 1/2 in. = 1 ft | Wall sections | 2 ft |
| 1-1/2 in. = 1 ft | Details | 8 in. |
| 1 in. = 20 ft (engineer's scale) | Site plans | 20 ft |
- Floor plan at 1/4 in. = 1 ft; a wall measures 5-3/4 in.: 5.75 ÷ 0.25 = 23 ft
- Site plan at 1 in. = 20 ft; a setback measures 1-1/4 in.: 1.25 × 20 = 25 ft
Lines and Symbols
Specifications and Order of Precedence
Specifications follow CSI MasterFormat, 50 divisions numbered 00 through 49. Each section has three parts: Part 1 General (administrative requirements and submittals), Part 2 Products, and Part 3 Execution. A prescriptive specification dictates materials and methods, a performance specification states the required result, and a proprietary specification names a product.
| Division | Title |
|---|---|
| 01 | General Requirements |
| 03 | Concrete |
| 04, 05 | Masonry; Metals |
| 06 | Wood, Plastics, and Composites |
| 07 | Thermal and Moisture Protection |
| 08 | Openings |
| 09 | Finishes |
| 22, 23, 26 | Plumbing; HVAC; Electrical |
- Change orders and addenda over the original documents
- Specifications over drawings
- Large-scale details over small-scale plans
- Written dimensions over scaled dimensions
Shop Drawings, Submittals, RFIs, and Change Orders
Shop drawings are prepared by the contractor, subcontractor, or supplier to show how an item, such as trusses, steel, or millwork, will be fabricated and installed. Division 01 sets the submittal procedures; Part 1 of each section lists the submittals required. The general contractor checks each one against the contract documents before forwarding it, and a submittal log tracks dates and status.
Finished reading?
Lock it in with a quick Planning and Estimating quiz.