Regulation of the Legal Profession · 3 min read
Admission to the Profession
Character and Fitness
Bar admission requires demonstration of good moral character and fitness to practice law. This requirement reflects the profession's self-regulatory nature and the public trust reposed in lawyers.
Character and fitness evaluations examine an applicant's background for indicators of honesty, trustworthiness, diligence, and reliability. Common areas of inquiry include criminal history, academic misconduct, financial responsibility, mental health history, substance abuse history, and prior employment conduct.
Criminal convictions do not automatically preclude admission. Bar examiners consider the nature and seriousness of the offense, the applicant's age at the time, evidence of rehabilitation, and the time elapsed since the conduct. Crimes involving dishonesty or breach of trust receive particular scrutiny because they bear directly on fitness to practice.
Financial irresponsibility, including bankruptcy, unpaid debts, and failure to file tax returns, may raise character concerns. Bar examiners distinguish between financial difficulties caused by circumstances beyond the applicant's control and those reflecting disregard for legal obligations.
Mental health conditions do not disqualify applicants from admission. The Americans with Disabilities Act limits the scope of mental health inquiries. Bar examiners may ask about current impairment affecting the ability to practice but generally cannot inquire into diagnosis or treatment history absent specific conduct-based concerns.
The applicant bears the burden of proving good character and fitness. The standard is whether the applicant's present character indicates the applicant can be trusted to practice law competently and ethically.
Admission Requirements
Admission to the bar typically requires graduation from an ABA-accredited law school, passage of the bar examination, passage of the MPRE, and clearance of character and fitness review.
The bar examination tests knowledge of substantive and procedural law. Most jurisdictions use the Uniform Bar Examination (UBE), which consists of the Multistate Bar Examination, the Multistate Essay Examination, and the Multistate Performance Test. Some jurisdictions administer their own examinations or supplement the UBE with jurisdiction-specific components.
Some jurisdictions permit diploma privilege, admitting graduates of in-state law schools without examination. Wisconsin is the primary example, admitting graduates of its two ABA-accredited law schools without requiring a bar examination.
Admission pro hac vice allows lawyers not admitted in a jurisdiction to appear in specific proceedings. Courts grant such admission on a case-by-case basis, typically requiring association with local counsel and a showing that the lawyer is in good standing elsewhere.
Temporary practice provisions in Model Rule 5.5 permit lawyers to provide legal services on a temporary basis in jurisdictions where they are not admitted under specified circumstances, including association with local counsel, relation to pending or potential proceedings, and relation to matters arising from the lawyer's home state practice.
Finished reading?
Lock it in with a quick Regulation of the Legal Profession quiz.