A sixth-grade teacher records a student's oral reading of a grade-level passage.
Text: The explorer carefully climbed the steep ridge before sunset.
Student: The explorer carelessly climbed the step ridge before sunset.
Text: She found a narrow trail that led to the summit.
Student: She found a narrow trial that led to the summit.
The student made no self-corrections. In the retelling, the student was confused about the explorer's route.
Which conclusion about the student's reading is best supported by the miscue pattern?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: C. The student attends to letter patterns but is not checking whether the words make sense.
Each substitution (carelessly, step, trial) shares most of its letters with the text word but changes or destroys the meaning, and none was self-corrected, so the student is using visual information without monitoring for sense. Meaning-preserving substitutions would look like path for trail, not trial. The confused retelling confirms that comprehension monitoring, not word knowledge, is the gap.