A second-grade teacher gives a developmental spelling inventory. Selected results for one student are shown below.
| Target word | Student spelling |
|---|
| ship | SHIP |
| drip | DRIP |
| boat | BOTE |
| train | TRANE |
| float | FLOTE |
| chase | CHAYS |
Based on these results, the student is MOST likely in which stage of spelling development?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. Within word pattern
The student spells short-vowel words, blends, and digraphs correctly and consistently marks long vowels, but confuses which long-vowel pattern to use (BOTE, TRANE, FLOTE, CHAYS), the hallmark of the within word pattern stage. A letter name–alphabetic speller would typically leave out the long-vowel marker altogether (BOT, TRAN) and would still confuse short vowels; syllables and affixes errors occur at syllable junctures in longer words.