Question 5 · Knowledge, Application, and Integration of Academic Content in the Curriculum
During shared reading of a pattern book, a kindergartner points to the words while reciting from memory: "I see an elephant." She points to "I" for "I," "see" for "see," and "an" for "an." As she says "el-e-phant," she points to "elephant" and then to the first two words on the next line, and then looks puzzled when she has run out of words. She knows most letter names and some letter sounds.
Which conclusion is best supported by this observation?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: C. She has not yet developed a stable concept of word in text.
Matching each spoken syllable of "elephant" to a separate printed word shows that one-to-one voice-print matching, the concept of word in text, is not yet stable. She moves left to right correctly, so directionality is in place, and the observation does not involve oral phoneme segmentation or miscues that would show cue use.